7 min read

What Restaurants Do Prep Cooks Make the Most Money at in Milwaukee, WI?

restaurants where prep cooks make most money in milwaukee cover image

Prep Cooks in Milwaukee earn an average hourly wage of about $15 per hour. However, this base wage is only part of the story when considering total earnings. While traditional tipping is less common for back-of-house roles like Prep Cooks compared to front-of-house positions, some establishments in Milwaukee do provide additional incentives and occasional bonuses that can add another $2 to $5 per hour in supplemental income.

This article explores which restaurants in Milwaukee pay the best wages to Prep Cooks and how different factors such as restaurant type and location influence earnings. We also provide advice on how to secure a higher-paying Prep Cook job in the city.

Top-Paying Restaurants for Prep Cooks in Milwaukee, WI

Milwaukee’s culinary scene spans a range of dining styles, and Prep Cooks looking to maximize their income should focus on establishments with strong reputations, robust customer bases and a commitment to staff compensation. Here are some of the top-paying restaurants where Prep Cooks currently find success:

1. Sanford Restaurant

Sanford is a beloved fine dining establishment known for its seasonal and locally sourced dishes. Prep Cooks benefit from competitive wages here, bolstered by a demanding kitchen environment that rewards skill and reliability.

2. Ardent

Ardent is a progressive, upscale restaurant that combines creative cuisine with a focus on hospitality. The kitchen is fast-paced and offers above-average pay rates to support the level of expertise required.

3. Lake Park Bistro

Renowned for its classic French-inspired dishes and scenic location near Lake Michigan, Lake Park Bistro offers strong hourly wages and supportive working conditions, reflecting its commitment to quality food and staff wellbeing.

4. Blue’s Egg

Blue’s Egg is a popular spot for breakfast and brunch, known for unique twists on American classics. Prep Cooks here enjoy consistent shifts with fair pay, along with the chance to work in a busy, high-volume kitchen.

5. Story Hill BKC

Story Hill BKC blends contemporary American cuisine with a relaxed atmosphere, attracting a steady crowd. The kitchen staff benefits from competitive pay and the opportunity to grow skills in a supportive environment.

Hiring for this role?
OR
Looking for top paid jobs?

The Impact of Restaurant Type on Prep Cook Earnings

Casual vs. Upscale Dining

Casual dining spots usually offer a standard hourly wage for Prep Cooks, often around the city’s average. These kitchen roles benefit from steady work but typically have limited tip income since tipping is rare for back-of-house staff. However, some casual restaurants include performance bonuses or shift differentials depending on volume.

Fine Dining and Upscale Establishments

Fine dining restaurants like Sanford or Ardent typically pay higher base wages to Prep Cooks to match the elevated skill requirements and fast-paced kitchen environment. Additionally, some of these kitchens offer incentives such as end-of-shift bonuses or profit-sharing that add to overall income.

Location and Certification

Restaurants in prime Milwaukee neighborhoods or near downtown tend to offer better pay because of higher dining volume and clientele spending power. Prep Cooks with certifications such as ServSafe or culinary school credentials also position themselves for higher wages and opportunities at premium eateries.

On tips specifically, Prep Cooks might see $2-$5 per hour in tip equivalents at certain venues, but generally, the bulk of their earnings comes from their hourly wage and other incentives.

How To Find a High Paying Prep Cook Job in Milwaukee

  • Obtain Relevant Certifications: Completing courses like ServSafe and basic culinary training increases your qualifications.
  • Focus on Upscale Venues: Target restaurants known for fine dining, as they often pay above average for skilled kitchen staff.
  • Build Experience: Gain experience in high-volume kitchens and display reliability to employers.
  • Network with Industry Professionals: Attend local culinary events or job fairs to meet hiring managers.
  • Prepare a Professional Resume: Highlight any prior kitchen roles, certifications and relevant skills.
  • Apply In-Person When Possible: Showing eagerness and professionalism can help you stand out from online-only applicants.
Hiring for this role?
OR
Looking for top paid jobs?

What’s the Outlook for Prep Cook Jobs in Milwaukee in 2025 and Beyond?

The employment outlook for Prep Cooks in Milwaukee is steady with moderate growth expected through 2025 and beyond. The city's growing culinary scene and expanding hospitality sector contribute to ongoing demand for skilled kitchen personnel.

According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, food preparation workers nationwide are expected to experience average growth rates, and Milwaukee’s emphasis on both new restaurant openings and revitalizing older dining establishments supports local opportunities.

Furthermore, trends such as farm-to-table dining and increased interest in diverse culinary styles will continue to drive the need for reliable Prep Cooks capable of handling fresh, seasonal ingredients efficiently.

Is a Prep Cook’s Salary Enough to Live Well in Milwaukee?

Milwaukee’s cost of living is relatively affordable compared to many metro areas, with an average hourly pay of $15 plus possible extra income from incentives or bonuses for Prep Cooks. This translates to approximately $31,000 to $35,000 annually before taxes.

Monthly expenses include rent averaging around $1,000 for a one-bedroom apartment in the city center, utilities at approximately $150 and groceries roughly $300 to $400 per month per individual.

With careful budgeting, a Prep Cook earning at or above the average wage in Milwaukee can cover living costs, save modestly and enjoy the city’s amenities, particularly if they benefit from supplemental income through bonuses or added incentives.

Our Criteria for Choosing Top-Paying Milwaukee Prep Cook Jobs

We selected these Milwaukee restaurants based on thorough evaluation of wage data, employee reviews and job listings to identify establishments that offer competitive pay to Prep Cooks.

Key factors include:

  • Pay rate and bonus opportunities: Focused on restaurants that combine a solid hourly base with extra financial incentives.
  • Reputation and kitchen environment: Prioritizing venues known for good working conditions and support for kitchen staff.
  • Location and clientele: Considering proximity to high-traffic areas and restaurants attracting well-spending customers.
  • Employee benefits: Restaurants offering stability through benefits and opportunities for advancement received extra attention.

These factors combine to highlight workplaces that provide the best overall earning potential and job satisfaction for Prep Cooks in Milwaukee.